Bullshit on Stilts: A Field Guide to Financial Bullshitology

Bullshitting ourselves? But of course!

Keli Alo & Mark Robinson Season 1 Episode 2

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 11:43

Delving into the area of why many people deny, delay, and defer critical financial decisions. Mark and Keli get into observations of what maybe going on behind the curtains of a consumer's decision-making procrastination? 

We love to hear your thoughts, questions, and ideas. Send us a text!

Developing your financial bullshit sniffer one episode at a time. 

Introducing Bullshit on Stilts

Speaker 1

welcome to bullshit on stilts , a podcast hosted by two guys with vast financial backgrounds and great bullshit sniffers who call out the cliche crap , spackle and flapdoodle spood by so-called experts across the landscape of financial advice identifying as doctors of bullshit ology . You can count on your steam hosts maybe knuckleheads to bring you a lively , if not deadly , mix of serious analysis , hijinks and tomfoolery , all within a 99.1% bullshit-free safe space . Let's get after

How People Bullshit Themselves

Speaker 1

it . How do people bullshit themselves ? How do people bullshit themselves ? Because there's a lot of folks out there and I think the primary operating mentality of our human being species is that we're probably the biggest bullshitters on stilts to ourselves . So how does that present itself when it comes to financial decision making ? And really it's about maybe some self-control or self-discipline . You want to comment on that , mark ?

Speaker 2

Well , first of all , we've got to get over this Lake Wobegon thing that we are all above average and all good-looking . This ain't so I'm sorry , what ? So we think that , for example , in managing risk , this won't happen to me , or I'll start tomorrow . And managing risk , this won't happen to me or I'll start tomorrow and all of these things come into play that are just rationalizations as a way of protecting ourselves from what we know is a potential train wreck based on our own behavior . So I think there's a tremendous amount of deferral , deflection , denial , that goes into us bullshitting ourselves and it all comes down to I'll

The Spending vs Saving Dilemma

Speaker 2

start tomorrow .

Speaker 1

Do you think that's driven by a fear of being sold something you don't need from a financial related decision or choice ? Is that why people defer decisions ? Is it because they're fearful that they'll make the wrong decision ? So no decision is better than making a wrong decision ? Where do you think that comes from ?

Speaker 2

Oh , I think that's very valid , because there is something called decision regret . Sure , and studies have shown too many options won't make a decision . And then when you do make a decision , there's decision regret . How does a person avoid decision regret ? You think through the decision-making process Each step . Do other options exist ? Now you're starting to solidify and coalesce around something that might actually make some sense . Yeah , and keep consistently applying whatever it is we decided to do .

Speaker 1

So that's a component right , just fearing of making the wrong decision . Another component is that I'm too busy having fun with the money I earn to save any of it , to put it aside for whatever reason , whether it's retirement , whether it's paying for an estate plan , whether it doesn't matter . But most people don't do that . They don't stop their spending in order to save a little bit . And people are typically spend first , save second . Personality types Some people save first , spend second and the interesting thing is one gentleman told me years ago it's always the first group that spends first , save second . That works for the second group , the savers that save first and spend second .

Speaker 2

And that's an anomaly , and I think it's dispositional , in other words , I mean it's psychological . They're just of that ilk , and there are others that go out and spend and I think , it's very difficult to get from a dispositional standpoint people to change .

Speaker 1

Sure , that's a behavior issue . So I had a person I was working with . Their comment to me was you know , one of our big goals is to be able to save up enough money annually to be able to take a really nice spring break trip with the family . We've never done that . We'd really like to do that .

Speaker 1

In working through their finances , it became apparent that every month they were spending $560 a month on gaming profiles . So what did they do when they came home ? Month on gaming

Money Doesn't Buy Happiness

Speaker 1

profiles ? So what did they do when they came home ? Mom , dad , kids they all got on their PlayStation fours , threes , xbox , whatever logged into their paid gaming account to then game , essentially to enjoy themselves , leisure and so forth . So my comment to them was you can't afford a $6,000 trip a year because you're spending $6,000 a year on leisure activity called digital gaming , and so they're unable to save because they're simply spending without thought , and the only thought they could come up with is not to get rid of that , but how do we make more money ? That was really their first approach to that not to exhibit self-control , not to save first , spend second , but spend first and then complain that we don't have enough money saved to face an emergency expense that comes down the pipe .

Speaker 1

Think this through .

Speaker 2

If they thought the solution was we'll just go make more money , and that is true , but Do you think that will really translate into savings , or will it just be more spending without the thought , which is what the pattern has been ?

Speaker 1

Behavior trumps it all , so behavior will that'll trump it .

Speaker 1

They will spend the additional money almost to a guaranteed level . One of the reasons and we've all heard this money doesn't create happiness . It actually creates more decisions than anything else , but it doesn't create happiness . Creates more decisions than anything else , but it doesn't create happiness . And just because you're earning more , there's a whole bunch of pent up spending that you haven't done because you couldn't afford it . Now you unlock that 10 to one says there's a couple of snowmobiles in the trailer in the driveway for this couple . Just because of the way they operate , they also say well , that's not going to happen , we're not going to live that long . Whatever , it is to rationalize why they're spending everything now . And the most crestfallen people I've ever met were the people that took on the perfect plan that's not going to happen to me . I'll never live that long . I know when I'm going to die . And then they live beyond that expectation and they have nothing prepared beyond that point . But boy did they enjoy that money while they were younger .

Speaker 2

So I think there are latent attributes that , if addressed properly , can get people to change their thinking , therefore their behavior . Let me build this out just a bit . So stay with me on this . Money doesn't buy happiness , but it does give us access to what brings us happiness , or what we've told does , and that's spending , buying stuff . So , while money itself doesn't the energy in money and there is a currency it allows us to go do the stuff that does bring us happiness , or at least so we think which is all stuff , yeah , and that's been inculcated into us through marketing for decades . Oh yeah , spend , spend , spend . Yep , you got problems ? Just go spend more money .

Speaker 1

That's right . Whatever your problem is in life , there's a product to make it better , to make it better .

Speaker 1

Absolutely . We certainly attempt to lower the bullshit factor right and we call a spade a spade . If you're 55

Avoiding Financial Self-Deception

Speaker 1

, you want to start planning for retirement and you intend to retire at 65 . You can have anything you want . You just can't have everything . And if you fail to plan , don't plan to retire . And if you plan to retire , then plan to be at some point impoverished because you didn't do what you needed to do .

Speaker 1

And some people don't want to hear that , but it's probably some of the most functional information if they're receiving it , that helps them choose maybe a different path . It might be you retire from your career with every intention to pick up a second career . Maybe it's consulting , because you have one of those backgrounds that everybody's looking for your intellectual brawn . But you don't have to work 50 , 60 hours a week for the corporation anymore as an example , retiring just so you can get a job . Well , that dog ain't going to hunt .

Speaker 1

People have this tendency to use the perfect plan , to use the that's not going to happen to me as a rationalizing event I think you said this before to just defer , procrastinate on a decision . It was nice , it didn't feel right . So I'm not going to do anything , but let me think about it . And they never address that pressing issue that they originally wanted to address because they couldn't get over the fear of making a bad decision . The fear of having 150 bucks a month not being in the check-in account because it's going into a life insurance policy , as an example , the fear of having to go on a financial diet in order to have your cake and sort of eat it too , down the road which is planning , saving first , paying yourself first , as well as taking care of the stuff that is part of the everyday lifestyle .

Speaker 1

I probably encountered more people in my career that said , hey , I don't want to know all that , I just need to find someone to do it for me . I've never encountered one of those types of personalities that were ever willing to get serious about understanding what the decisions they're facing , what they imply , because they're just looking for someone that they kind of like almost like it's a dating approach . If I like you we had a good conversation I trust you . Here's all my money . Take care of it the way you see fit . Don't make me answer questions , because I just don't know any of this stuff . What do you think ? Tell me what to do . It's in those relationships that people are taken advantage of yes Very frequently .

Speaker 1

And then they say woe is me , I didn't know that , they didn't tell me that . Yet every time you met them for the last seven years you said I don't understand this , I don't get it , Just do what you think is right for me . But then when you find out something's wrong or whatever , shame on them , not on you . So you're bullshitting yourself . You made the decision to remain ignorant and not give a damn with the express intent to maintain the right to be disappointed and take that person to arbitration or whatever the case might be . That's easier than spending a little time learning how to be better at making your own decisions , excluding product and service sales .

Speaker 1

Big difference huge difference but we can't and we don't make people do things . They either will or they won't .

Speaker 2

What we're looking for , frankly , for the podcast are people that truly do want to get the bullshit off the stilts , and that has to do with what we perceive , how we integrate what we hear , the bullshit , how we protect ourselves from it and how we address the worst bullshit which

Getting Real About Financial Choices

Speaker 2

is within us . Yeah , and say , look , I'm ready to get real here . What do we need to do ? Well , that's the last part of it is what do we need to think about ? What do we need to correct ? How do we set up a new way of thinking , Because the old way of thinking that got you into trouble is not the same mindset and way of thinking that's going to get you out of trouble .

Speaker 1

We find that when people get to talk to experts and collaborate and brainstorm with them , throwing good ideas , bad ideas , on the table , talking about it , the sense that I can is that all there is to this . You mean , are you kidding me ? That takes the chalk blocks out from underneath the race car tires . In many instances , when the profile of the individual is , I need to get busy . I'm tired of being tired . I know I can do this . I just need an ally on my side of the table , not trying to sell me crap , but helping me translate all this French from financial services into a language I get .